Skip to Content

Book Review: The Birdcage Library by Freya Berry

The Birdcage Library is a novel by bestselling author Freya Berry, whose debut novel The Dictator’s Wife was featured on BBC’s Between The Covers.

It tells the story of It tells the story of Emily Blackwood, a plant-hunter in 1932, who’s tasked with finding hidden treasure in a remote Scottish castle. But her discovery of an old diary, filled with dark secrets and warnings, leads her on a different kind of hunt—one that may endanger her own life.

Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

Genre: Historical Fiction

Author: Freya Berry

Buy: Amazon | Waterstones

Published: 2023

Book Blurb

The answers to a puzzle lie hidden within an old book. Open The Birdcage Library and let the treasure hunt begin…

The year is 1882, and the most important thing, unknown reader, is this: The man I love is trying to kill me.

It’s 1932 and adventuress and plant-hunter Emily Blackwood accepts a commission from Heinrich Vogel, a former dealer of exotic animals in Manhattan, living now with his macabre collection in a remote Scottish castle.

Emily is tasked to find a long-lost treasure which Heinrich believes has been hidden within the castle walls. But instead she discovers the pages of a diary, written by Hester Vogel, who died after falling from the Brooklyn Bridge.

Hester’s diary leads Emily to an old book The Birdcage Library and into a treasure hunt of another kind, one that will take her down a dangerous path for clues, and force her to confront her own darkest secret…

The Birdcage Library Book Review

The Birdcage Library is a gothic, atmospheric tale complete with treasure hunt and engaging characters. Everything I love!

The story unfolds across two timelines: Hester Vogel’s chilling diary entries from 1882 and Emily Blackwood’s investigation in 1932.

Hester’s words hint at dark secrets and danger, while Emily’s search for both the treasure and the truth takes place in a remote Scottish castle with a few ghosts of its own. Right from the start, there’s an eerie feeling that something big is lurking beneath the surface.

I found both timelines and perspectives worked really well but I was especially drawn to Hester’s story. It felt haunting and almost claustrophobic as she writes about her growing isolation and sense of confinement. It really captures how trapped women often felt in that era, and I found myself rooting for her in every entry.

Meanwhile, Emily’s more modern quest has her unearthing clues from Hester’s past, and I enjoyed how the story slotted into place. However, there was a subplot in Emily’s timeline that felt a bit pointless. I don’t want to give any spoilers so I’ll just say it wasn’t fully developed and didn’t add much to the main storyline.

The story is quite slow paced but I don’t mind that. It added a creeping suspense that fit perfectly with the castle setting. I did guess the twist before the big reveal, but I still felt it didn’t spoil my enjoyment of the story.

Overall, The Birdcage Library is a beautifully written story with layers of suspense and mystery. I’d definitely read more books by Freya Berry.

What to read next

If you’ve read and enjoyed The Birdcage Library, I’d suggest reading Freya Berry’s debut novel, The Dictator’s Wife which was featured on BBC’s Between the Covers.

If you’re a fan of stories with old houses full of secrets, you may also enjoy The Secrets of Hartwood Hall.